Apple loses two more dodgy UK court cases against HTC and Samsung

We’ve given up trying to keep up with Apple’s generally dubious claims to get rival products banned off the shelves around the world, but were pleased to discover that their latest attempts against HTC and Samsung in the UK have been booted out of  court.

Today, the High Court of England & Wales declared that  Samsung’s Galaxy Tab tablet devices do not infringe on Apple designs, with the court finding recognisable differences between the Galaxy Tab 7.7, Galaxy Tab 10.1 and Galaxy Tab 8.9 tablets and the Apple iPads.

Outrageously, Apple had insisted that the three Samsung tablet products were guilty on infringing on their  design rights, by virtue of them having  features such as ‘slightly rounded corners,’ ‘a flat transparent surface without any ornamentation,’ and ‘a thin profile.’

The High Court rightly kicked this crap out of court, with Samsung’s defence team referring to approximately “50 examples of prior art, or designs that were previously created or patented, from before 2004”.

We can’t imagine any normal person has ever gone into a shop to buy an iPad and mistakenly bought a Samsung Galaxy instead, so we’re pleased to see Apple’s spurious claims getting such thrift. [Source]

HTC case defeat

Last week, Apple also lost its case against HTC over  four technologies that Apple had claimed as its own, including the ‘swipe to unlock feature’ found on their Android handsets (see archive video below).

The judge ruled that Apple’s slide-to-unlock feature was an “obvious” development in the light of a similar function been seen in Microsoft’s CE system [BBC].

A win for consumers

Sadly, these defeats are unlikely to stop Apple continuing their campaign of trying to block rival products elsewhere in the world with yet more spurious claims, but we’d count their failure to secure wins in the UK a victory for consumers, common sense and a healthy competitive electronics market.

Tags: