So, the LaCie 2TB external hard drive which we wrote such nice things about last year has started to make really nasty clicking noises, less than a year into its life.
The noises weren’t the normal sound of a hard drive going about its business, mind, but big, loud, clunky, teeth-grating, mechanical noises that almost always spell impending doom. So we immediately got in touch with the manufacturers.
Easy to use? Err..
With LaCie making a big deal that their drives are “easy to set up” and “effortless” to use, we felt sure that the extra we paid for this premium product would be rewarded by a really simple fix – or perhaps a straight replacement.
After an initial email exchange had convinced them that the clicking we were hearing really was not the usual behaviour of a healthy hard drive, we waited to see how they could help.
And then we got their answer: all 593 words of it, written in the kind of geek-speak that would send your average non-techie consumer scratching their heads in bafflement.
Here’s the “easy” fix…
LaCie started by instructing us to back up the entire contents of the drive that we’d, err, been using as a back up, and transferring the content some place else before deleting all the content on the drive.
Next up was a trip into the dark and mysterious wastelands of DOS (DOS? Hello? This is 2011!) to piddle about with text commands before being asked to input some arcane commands into the disk management tools interface.
Even seasoned computer users like us never feel particularly good about messing about with DOS commands, but what on earth is the company doing expecting regular consumers to go through all this palaver?
We understand that hard drives go on the blink sometimes, but when you’re talking about a drive that’s less than a year old from a premium brand we certainly expected something a little more user-friendly.
Beef has been despatched
So, we’ve expressed our beef in the direction of LaCie and we’ll keep you updated as to how this all pans out.
Their response will certainly influence whether we can recommend their drives in the future.
Here’s their original tech support response below. Snappy, isn’t it?
Please try to reformat the drove [sic] as it might be suffering from Volume corruption.
Volume corruption can occur from a variety of causes. To fix this problem, the best way is to reinitialize the drive, then reformat it. If a backup of the corrupted drive is not available, recovering the data should be done first. The reformatting process will erase the data permanently, so it must be recovered prior to attempting to fix it.
IMPORTANT NOTE: Following the procedure below will ERASE ALL DATA on the drive. Prior to following these directions, verify important data is stored securely on a different storage device.
Begin by clicking Start, then Run. If “Run” is not available, press the [windows button] and [R] on the keyboard at the same time.
In the box, type:
A DOS window will open. Use a command called “diskpart” to perform the beginning part of the format process.
then press enter. The system will change the prompt to say DISKPART>
Next, type list disk, then press enter. Doing so will display a list of all hard drives attached, the size of the drives, and the disk number assigned.
Identify the corrupted disk. This can be difficult if there are multiple, identical disks. If this is the case, unplug the drive, then type list disk again. Note which drive is missing, then reconnect it. Type list disk once again to get the new listing, and identify the proper drive.
The next step is to target the right disk with the program. Type:
followed by the corrupted disk’s disk number. In the example, we used the command:
select disk 2
Disk 2 is the problematic one, so that was correct. This differs from system to system, so ensure the correct disk is selected. Press enter when ready.
Finally, type the command:
then press enter. This will erase the partition information, and allow a new format to be applied. The message “DiskPart succeeded in cleaning the disk.” The DOS window can be closed, now.
The next step is to apply a new format to the disk, and perform a test to see if the drive is physically working properly. Use a program called Disk Management to do this.
To access the Disk Management program, press [windows button] + [R] again to open the Run window.
Type the command:
The Disk Management program will open. If a window called the “Initialize and Convert Wizard” appears, click cancel.
The top frame lists partition summaries for connected drives. The bottom frame shows how the disks are physically related to these partitions. We are interested primarily in the bottom frame. Look for the disk number selected earlier in the DiskPart program. It should have a different icon (a red arrow, specifically.)
Right-click that symbol, and choose to “Initialize Disk”. A new window will appear asking for confirmation. Confirm this command.
When it has completed, it will now appear like so:
Next, space must be allocated to hold files. Computers call these “Partitions.” Right-click the area marked “Unallocated”, and choose to make a “New Simple Volume.”
For the following choices presented, the default is the most desirable option. It will set up the entire disk as one drive, make it the Windows file format, and run a read/write test on the drive. Read each question carefully to ensure that it will meet any required needs, as reformatting erases the data, again.
Once it has completed, the drive will be accessible.
Thanks, and please let me know your results.